Current:Home > StocksCity’s red-light camera program was lawful after all, North Carolina justices say-InfoLens
City’s red-light camera program was lawful after all, North Carolina justices say
View Date:2024-12-23 15:09:54
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A pair of North Carolina local governments didn’t skirt state laws by creating a red-light camera enforcement system where nearly a fourth of collected penalties failed to remain within the area school district, the state Supreme Court ruled Thursday.
The 5-1 decision reverses a March 2022 Court of Appeals opinion that declared the city of Greenville’s program unconstitutional.
Although the city council discontinued the program months later, the cost-sharing arrangement between the city and the Pitt County Board of Education was also upheld by the state’s highest court. That could provide a pathway for other municipalities who want a red-light program but can’t make it work financially.
A provision within the state constitution says the “clear proceeds” of all fines collected for such violations must be “used exclusively for maintaining free public schools.” The General Assembly and courts have said a county school system must receive at least 90% of the total penalties and fines collected to meet the definition of ”clear proceeds.”
Roughly 20 North Carolina towns and cities have been authorized by the legislature to operate traffic-control photograph programs. Greenville contracted in 2017 with an Arizona company to install and operate the red-light cameras. Motorists photographed driving through red lights received citations and faced a $100 penalty.
In 2016, however, the legislature voted to give Greenville and the Pitt school board the ability to negotiate a cost-sharing and reimbursement arrangement. Under the agreed-upon plan, Greenville would first pay the school board 100% of the money collected. Then the school board would turn around and pay city invoices — covering things like fees for the Arizona company, the salary and benefits for a police officer that ran the program, and other expenses.
When all those payments were complete, the Pitt school board received over a roughly two-year period 72% of the $2.5 million collected.
In 2019, two motorists who were cited for red-light violations sued the city and the school board, saying the program and the cost-sharing agreement violated state laws and the constitution. Writing Thursday’s majority opinion, Associate Justice Anita Earls said the two motorists had legal standing to sue as taxpayers.
But Earls said it was apparent through the 2016 law and other context that the General Assembly aimed to grant Greenville and the Pitt County board flexibility on the requirement that the municipality could keep no more than 10% of the fines. Greenville had initiated a red-light program once before, in the 2000s, but abandoned it a few years later, saying the 10% limit made the program economically infeasible, the opinion read.
As for the language in the state constitution, Pitt County schools benefit from the “clear proceeds” of the red-light penalties because Greenville “recoups only the ‘reasonable costs of collection,’” Earls said.
“Greenville does not profit from the arrangement or use the fines to pad its general operating budget,” Earls wrote, adding that without the funding arrangement, “the program would not exist and Pitt County schools would lose an important pillar of financial support.”
Associate Justice Phil Berger, writing a dissenting opinion, said the funding arrangement cannot be squared with the constitution, with the state law requiring at least a 90% payout, “with basic math, or common definitions.”
“The majority’s assertion that a local bill can override these statutory and constitutional strictures is the legal equivalent of saying 2+2=5,” Berger wrote.
Associate Justice Richard Dietz, who was on the Court of Appeals panel that ruled in 2022, didn’t participate in the Supreme Court’s consideration of the case.
veryGood! (9546)
Related
- ‘Heretic’ and Hugh Grant debut with $11 million, but ‘Venom: The Last Dance’ tops box office again
- How can I resolve a hostile email exchange before it escalates? Ask HR
- Dancing With the Stars' Gleb Savchenko Shares Message to Artem Chigvintsev Amid Divorce
- Eva Mendes Reveals Whether She'd Ever Return to Acting
- Man charged with murder in fatal shooting of 2 workers at Chicago’s Navy Pier
- National Cheeseburger Day 2024: Get deals at McDonald's, Burger King, Wendy's, more
- NASA plans for launch of Europa Clipper: What to know about craft's search for life
- Boar's Head to 'permanently discontinue' liverwurst after fatal listeria outbreak
- Ryan Reynolds Clarifies Taylor Swift’s Role as Godmother to His Kids With Blake Lively
- A bewildered seal found itself in the mouth of a humpback whale
Ranking
- Tua Tagovailoa tackle: Dolphins QB laughs off taking knee to head vs. Rams on 'MNF'
- NAACP president urges Missouri governor to halt execution planned for next week
- Boy trapped between large boulders for 9 hours saved by New Hampshire firefighters
- Ringo Starr guides a submarine of singalongs with his All Starr band: Review
- Shaun White Reveals How He and Fiancée Nina Dobrev Overcome Struggles in Their Relationship
- The Laneige Holiday Collection 2024 Is Here: Hurry to Grab Limited-Edition Bestsellers, Value Sets & More
- Texas lawmakers show bipartisan support to try to stop a man’s execution
- Sean “Diddy” Combs Pleads Not Guilty in Sex Trafficking Case After Arrest
Recommendation
-
Burger King is giving away a million Whoppers for $1: Here's how to get one
-
A Dangerous Chemical Is Fouling Niagara Falls’ Air. New York State Hasn’t Put a Stop to It
-
Ukraine boxing champion Oleksandr Usyk released after brief detention in Poland
-
Dancing With the Stars' Anna Delvey Reveals Her Hidden Talent—And It's Not Reinventing Herself
-
Stop What You're Doing—Moo Deng Just Dropped Her First Single
-
Proof You're Probably Saying Olympian Ilona Maher's Name Wrong
-
Kate Middleton Reaches New Milestone After Completing Chemotherapy for Cancer
-
Ping pong balls thrown at Atlanta city council members in protest of mayor, 'Cop City'